The blog of the Dominican student brothers at Blackfriars, Oxford.

Built on the four pillars of our Dominican life – preaching, prayer, study, and community – Godzdogz offers many resources for exploring the Catholic Faith today.
Read more.

Our Lady of Lourdes

Saturday, February 11, 2017

To my shame, I’ve never actually been to Lourdes. Nor have I been to any of the other apparition sites, or great shrines of Marian devotion; the notable exception being, of course, England’s own Nazareth, Walsingham, which I’ve been to many times over. But this lack of experience has always left me feeling quite at sea whenever I have to talk about Lourdes, or Fatima, or really any other place associated with Our Lady. 

In my mind, Our Lady of Lourdes is associated with endless dedications of schools, parishes, hospitals, and dioceses, all marking them out as foundations of the somewhat truncated Second Spring of English Catholicism in the nineteenth century. And this perhaps explains why there is a particular kind of piety associated with Lourdes, and a kind of piety people feel uncomfortable with today. This in spite of the fact that millions of people still flock to Lourdes each year to make pilgrimage, find a cure, and do penance. My own first exposure to this kind of traditional piety was seen through the lens of the snobbery that the Anglicanism of my youth aimed at what it considered simplistic and superstitious piety. It’s an uneasiness found even with those raised as Catholics. For example Seamus Heaney, who was raised in County Derry in the 1940s and 1950s, continually returns to the themes of Northern Irish Catholicism throughout his poetry and other writing. He wrote of a Catholicism which was formed by family Rosary and praying the Litany of Loretto and describing it as mournful, politically passive, and turning his community in to a group of people who ‘stoop along’ as just another one of the venerators. 

Is he right? Well, no, and he's particularly wrong when we consider the story of today’s feast day. St Bernadette herself was a poorly educated peasant girl, and, interestingly given how much we hear of a crisis in catechesis, was herself a product of an appalling religious education system. Indeed it was her own lack of education that made her account of the apparitions all the more believable. Each evening at Vespers we sing Mary’s hymn of praise to God, which celebrates the fact that God has ‘…cast the mighty from their thrones, and raised up the lowly’ and today’s feast is a celebration of that raising of the lowly. From its beginning with the apparition of a lady in white to a poor peasant girl, up to the present day pilgrims who come to the site in search of healing and forgiveness, Lourdes testifies to the dignity of those considered lowly and poor.

Br Albert Elias Robertson O.P.

Br Albert Elias was born in Surrey and went to university at the London School of Economics, where he read Social Anthropology before going to Oxford, where he read for an MPhil in Material Anthropology. After studies, he had a propaedeutic year in three Anglican parishes in north London. He became a Catholic in 2013 and worked for a short time in London living at St Patrick’s Soho before entering the noviciate in 2015. Br Albert helps to run the Thomistic Institute and so has an interest in promoting the theology of St Thomas as well as Patristics. In his spare time he likes to read novels [lots]. | albert.robertson@english.op.org


Richard Patterson commented on 11-Feb-2017 12:32 PM
You have some very good insights here. Thank you. Gycmd
frank o'shea commented on 12-Feb-2017 03:53 PM
Places where Our Blessed Lady has given as of significance to Her, are hugely important. I learnt this only last August. I also learnt that She will call you to come visit one of Her designated spots - if She desires your attendance.
Should you receive a persistent nagging to go - then do not hesitate as there, She will surprise you in a manner undreamed of.
I can state this having experienced Her presence by such a persistent nagging.

p.s. She also caused me to entirely turn away from Medjugorje.

Post a Comment

Captcha Image
Follow us
Meet the Student Brothers

Meet the Student Brothers



Featured Series

Featured Series

Recent posts


Liturgical index

All tags & authors


Upcoming events

View the full calendar